Showing posts with label Historically. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Historically. Show all posts

Monday, November 16, 2026

What is the most historically inaccurate Bollywood movie ever made about a historical event or character (excluding mythological)? Why do you think so?

 Mohenjo-Daro

The film is a joke in the name of history.

They called their place Mohenjo-Daro. Didn't the makers knew that Mohenjo-Daro means the "Mound of Dead"? It was a name given to it in modern times because of its burials. According to Iravatham Mahadevan the name of the city was perhaps Kukkutarma. Why would anyone in their sense call their place Mound of dead man.

Secondly they have shown horses in Mohanjo-Daro and called it Ghoda. First of all horses are not found from Mohenjo-Daro and secondly Ghoda is a Prakrit term and Apabhrnsh of Ghotaka and scholars suggest that Harappan civilization most probably spoke Elamo Dravidian. The evidence of horse like remains are discovered from Surkotada and even that is historically disputed.

In the end they have shown the flood theory for the destruction of city (such theories have been rejected) and shown them reaching Ganga coast. If that is a reference to Vedic civilization then they forgot that Early Vedic civilization originated in Sapta Sindhu and Ganga is significantly mentioned in Later Vedic only. Also there are so many differences in Harappan and Vedic civilization.

Pooja Hegde’s character wears elaborate, feathered, and glamorous tribal/fantasy headdresses and costumes that bear little resemblance to actual Harappan terra-cotta art or artifacts. Parts of the aesthetic lean closer to ancient Egypt or Mesopotamia than the Indus Valley.

The film includes a Roman-style gladiatorial arena and public blood-sport spectacles, which did not exist in the peaceful, urban, trade-focused Indus Valley cities. Infact we haven't found any strong evidence of violence, war or weapons from the Harappan civilization. So why was Hrithik fighting with a crocodile or fighting in the arena. Have we found any evidence of fighting arena from the civilization? Absolutely no. And the things we actually find from the civilization like the Great Bath is barely mentioned in the film.

Ashutosh Gowarikar claimed that he read more than 300 books on the subject. I wish to know where was this knowledge applied because the whole story was so generic.

They made a love story out of Harappan civilization. It would have made no difference had they placed it in 2015 CE instead of BCE because the background hardly played any role in the narrative.