We know that Bhagavan controls everything. He alone is responsible for the creation, sustenance, and dissolution of the universe. And not only this universe, but He is the creator, sustainer, and destroyer of the infinite universes too. He created us, entered within us, and is present within us as Paramatma. As per His will, I, you, and everybody and everything work.
For example, you see yourself in the mirror. You raise your hand. The reflection too raises its hands. That means, whatever you do, your reflection does the same. So, in this example, you are bimba, and the reflection is pratibimba. In a similar way, Bhagavan, who is different from the jiva, is the bimba and the jiva is the pratibimba; that is, it does whatever the Bhagavan present within it would make it do.
He within us makes us do things. Everything is under His control. Even a twig doesn’t move without His will. He is present in our mind, inspiring us to do activities. He is present in our heart, making sure that all body functions happen properly. He, as Vaishvanara, digests the food within us. He does so much for us. But then, if we say that only Bhagavan is the doer and the jiva or soul doesn’t do anything, then it makes Bhagavan a very cruel person. Because He is the only one who makes us do things, be it good things or bad things.
If He makes us do bad things that are not recommended in the Shaastras, then the punishment should also be given to Bhagavan only, and not to us. The Shaastras are known as Shaastras because they do shaasana over us, telling us which is right and which is wrong, and instructing us towards the right path. But if the soul is just a mere observer and Bhagavan is the sole doer, then the Shaastras are not for the soul, because whatever we do is not done by us, and Bhagavan makes us do it.
So, here it is not the case that Bhagavan is doing everything and the soul or jiva doesn’t possess the doership at all. The soul too does possess the doership. Every soul has three attributes in it. One is knowledge. Another is desire. And the third one is effort. Whenever we do things, we have the knowledge of what we are doing. We should have the desire to do that, and we should put effort into doing that work.
Let me explain with an example. For example, let’s say I want to write an essay. I have the basic knowledge that, ‘Yes, I want to write an essay. And to write an essay, I need a pen and paper.’ Now, I have the desire to write the essay. And then, I take the pen and start writing the essay on the paper. This is my effort to perform that task. Without these three, no work is possible.
And this knowledge, desire, and effort are under the control of Bhagavan. The jiva possesses these three attributes and does its work accordingly, but then the jiva, or the soul, is dependent on the Supreme Bhagavan for this. The bimba and pratibimba that I explained above are correct, even as per the shaastras. Bhagavan inspires the knowledge, desire, and effort within us, as per our inherent nature.
This inherent nature is what we call the Svabhaava or Jiva Svabhaava. Let me again take an example. For example, consider a school. An exam took place, and the teachers were checking the students' exam papers. Assume there are four students. Student A, Student B, Student C, and Student D. Now, Student A wrote all the answers correctly. But then, when the teacher checked his/her overall academic performance, then it came out to be very nice.
He had completed all assignments, homework, submissions, and practicals on time, was regular in classes, and had studied and enjoyed the whole year. The teacher concludes that, ‘Yes, this student is a good student,’ and gives him/her good marks. Now, in case of Student B, he was not regular, not completed any homework, and hadn’t studied anything. And in the exam, he wrote all the wrong answers. Then, the teacher would obviously give fewer marks to him/her compared to Student A.
Now, comes Student C. He too hadn’t done any assignments, practicals, or homework, and wasn’t even regular in the classes, and hadn’t even studied a bit, due to some bad influence. But it was observed that he/she had written correct answers. This was the kind of student who never studied due to bad influence. But eventually, he overcame the bad influence, studied well, and scored good marks in the examination. So, the teacher gave him marks. But then, in the case of Student D, the case was different.
Student D was also like Student C, but he didn’t even study during the exam. But his answers were all correct. But then, the teacher feels skeptical about his answers, as to how this student wrote such correct answers? But then, the teacher calls the student and asks about the answer, and he doesn’t know the answer, then the teacher considers it as a copy case, and deducts the marks.
By this example, let’s understand the jiva svabhaava.
1. Student A: Saatvika Jiva.
2. Student B: Taamasa Jiva.
3. Student C: Jiva who is inherently good but has a bad influence. But then, he studies, overcomes the bad influence, and scores well.
4. Student D: An exceptional case, which can also happen.
The overall academic performance in the example is what is the Jiva Svabhaava in this case. Bhagavan, as per the Jiva’s Svabhaava, inspires him/her to do the karmas. He doesn’t go to change the Svabhaava of the jiva, because it would destroy the very essence of the jiva. It is like saying, ‘Change Neem into jaggery,’ which is not possible, because neem is neem and jaggery is jaggery, and they have their respective Svabhaava of being bitter and sweet, respectively.
But if a jiva is a good jiva or a Saatvika Jiva, then Bhagavan inspires their mind to do good karmas and then grants them Moksha. Therefore, they have the knowledge that they have to do karmas that please Bhagavan, have the desire to worship Bhagavan, and put effort into doing it. If the jiva is a bad jiva or a taamasa jiva, Bhagavan inspires their mind to do bad karmas.
So, that’s why they have the knowledge that they have to do karmas which are not pleasing to Bhagavan, have to desire to hate Bhagavan, and they even put effort into doing all the things which don’t bring pleasure to Bhagavan. But if a jiva is good, it can become bad due to some bad influence. So, in that case, since the evilness isn’t the inherent nature of that jiva, Bhagavan removes that evil influence from the jiva and brings it back to its original inherent nature, or its original svabhaava, which is good svabhaava.
And then, that jiva can continue being good and can do saadhana and attain Bhagavan. So, Bhagavan is an ocean of compassion and is the kindest personality in the whole infinite universes, who grants Moksha to the jivas who worship Him and live with a clean and egoless mind, and the jivas who hate Him hate everyone and always aim to destroy everything, killing others and all, are Taamasic jivas and end up falling into the eternal hell. For the jivas who are more attracted towards materialistic things, or the mode of passion, are Rajasika Jivas. They are nitya samsaris, which means they keep on rotating in the cycle of birth and death.
So, in conclusion, I would like to say that the soul is not just a mere observer; it too possesses doership. It has knowledge, desire, and effort as its attributes, due to which it performs karma, but these three attributes are under the control of Bhagavan, who is independent and different from the jiva. He inspires our mind with the knowledge, desire, and effort of doing karma, as per our inherent nature, which is known as svabhaava.
Note: The student example above was just for the sake of explanation and is not meant to demean anyone, because I myself am a college student.
Hope this helps!
Jay SriRam!
ShriKrishnarpanamastu!