Showing posts with label Films. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Films. Show all posts

Thursday, November 5, 2026

What makes "Lagaan" one of the toughest Bollywood films ever made, and why did so many big actors initially turn it down?

 Almost every top Bollywood star rejected Lagaan’s bizarre pitch for a four-hour epic about villagers playing cricket. The 113°F desert shoot with 10,000 extras proved even more brutal.

At a time when Bollywood was dominated by glossy romances and action films, the concept of a sports-period drama about escaping a tax burden was widely seen as an enormous financial risk. Director Ashutosh Gowariker first took the script to Shah Rukh Khan, who declined. Abhishek Bachchan was considered but also passed. Even Aamir Khan rejected the initial premise. "When I first heard the script, I thought, 'What a bizarre idea. People wearing dhotis and playing cricket?'" Khan later recalled. Gowariker spent five months rewriting the script. When Khan finally agreed to star, no established studio was willing to back a sports-period drama, forcing him to launch his own production company to fund the movie.

The production itself became one of the most difficult in Indian cinema history. Gowariker demanded a completely arid, drought-stricken look for the fictional village of Champaner. He found it in the remote villages near Bhuj in the Kutch district of Gujarat, a barren region known for its unforgiving climate.

For the first time in mainstream Bollywood, the film was shot on a single, start-to-finish six-month schedule instead of fragmented dates. The logistical hurdles were substantial. The crew had to construct an entire village from scratch and build a residential apartment complex to house over 300 cast and crew members in the middle of a desert.

In the relentless heat, actors had to perform sports choreography while wearing thick, historically accurate costumes, including heavy wool uniforms for the British cast members.

Adding to the difficulty was the film's use of sync sound—recording audio live on location—which was practically unheard of in Bollywood at the time, as studios almost exclusively dubbed their films in post-production. This meant that during the climax, Gowariker and his team had to enforce absolute silence among the thousands of local villagers brought in as extras, ensuring no background noise ruined the dialogue takes.

A cricket match in Nainital, India, in 1899. The script for Lagaan capitalized on the historical reality of British colonial officers organizing matches throughout the Victorian era. Source: Wikimedia Commons.

Friday, October 30, 2026

What is the worst film from good directors?

 

Ramesh Sippy directed the all time classic Sholay, and Shakti that was a true clash of the titans- Amitabh Bachchan and Dileep Kumar.

He gave us that delightful entertainer Seeta aur Geeta, female version of Ram Aur Shyam.

And the emotionally captivating Andaz that explored the love story between a single mother and a widower in a very sensitive manner.

Shaan was quite a good entertainer, with a rather James Bond style vibe.

Saagar while a bit long and drawn out, was still a watchable love triangle with great performances by Kamal Hassan, Rishi Kapoor and Dimple Kapadia.

And then he made Brashtachaar

A movie about political corruption that had Rekha, Mithun Chakraborty and Rajnikanth in a cameo. While the story looked good on paper, the execution was terribly bad, with over the top melodrama, a plot that is all over the place, screenplay that just keeps plodding along, too many songs interrupting the flow, you wonder if this is the same director who made Sholay that never had one dull moment. And above all a terribly cringe rape scene involving Anupam Kher and Shilpa Shirodkar, that is designed more to tittilate than evoking disgust.

Ramesh Sippy was never the same after this, his Akalya was no great shakes but redeemed by Amitabh Bachchan, while Zamaana Deewana was utter garbage. Fortunately after that he stuck to production and TV, ensuring he did not end up a parody like some of his contemporary directors.

Tuesday, October 13, 2026

Why are there no Indian English language movies like Finding Fanny being made anymore?

 English language movies are made in Bollywood but they are generally low budget films. There isn’t a big market for Indian English language. There have been many award winning English films that won National awards but none of them were commercially successful. Hyderabad Blues was perhaps one of the rare successful English movies but it was made on a shoestring budget of 25 lakhs and earned just 67 lakhs. Finding Fanny is perhaps the highest grossing Indian English language film (I could be wrong but I cannot recollect any other Indian english language indian film to cross even 10 crores).

But even that failed at the box office. Amitabh, Preity Zinta and Rituporno Ghosh failed with The Last Lear. Homi Adjania the director of Finding Fanny had earlier made Being Cyrus with Saif Ali Khan and Dimple Kapadia and that too failed. Years ago Shashi Kapoor had produced and Aparna Sen directed 36 Chowringee Lane, an English language Indian film which won 3 National awards and is considered one of the finest movies of Indian cinema but yet it failed so badly that Shashi Kapoor was in heavy debts. Years later in 2017 Aparna Sen again made an English film Sonata which also failed badly. Shabana Azmi has worked in Sonata apart from other english films like The Morning Raga. Shobana won a National award for English film Mitr my Friend, Konkana won for Mr. and Mrs Iyer also made by her mother Aparna Sen. Aparna Sen is one director who has made English language Indian films like these and 15 Park Aveneu all movies winning National awards but none getting commercial success..

Among male actors, Naseruddin Shah has continued to work in some English Language Indian films like The Blueberry Hunt, The Coffinmaker (with Randeep Hooda), The Mango Dreams (with Pankaj Tripathi). But such films are meant for Film festivals and not commercial release. Just recently Yash made film Toxic in two languages- Kannada and English. Why they decided to shoot the film in English is beyond my understanding but the result was a disaster of epic proportions with the english version earning only 3.16 lakh rupees!!

It is a sad reality but Indians prefer to watch Hollywood films in english but not Indian films. Even the great stars like Mamooty, Amitabh, Shobhana, Deepika, Naseer, Konkana etc couldn't salvage them. Interestingly even SRK and Manoj Bajpai worked in a National award winning English language Indian film In Which Annie Gives it to those ones, at a time when they were unknown. And despite their massive stardom this film remains little known even now.

What are the famous films where Aamir Khan and Juhi Chawla acted together before their fallout?

 Juhi Chawla and Aamir Khan pair has worked in 7 films out of which 3 films were major hits, one did average business and 3 were flops/disasters

Their first film together was Qayamat se Qayamat Tak. Many people consider it to be their debut film which is not true. Aamir made his debut with Holi and Juhi Chawla with Sultanat. But they got recognition from this film. QSQT was also the directorial debut of Mansoor Khan, son of Naseer Hussain (Naseer Hussain was on the down with 3 consecutive flops) and cousin of Aamir Khan. This film launched many careers- Aamir, Juhi, Mansoor, Anand Milind, Udit Narayan etc. The film was sold for 1.50 crores and earned 5 crores nett becoming a huge blockbuster. The music of QSQT revived the romantic genre in Bollywood again. The film won 2 National Awards and multiple Filmfare. Aamir Khan won a National award Special Mention for QSQT and Raakh. Both Aamir and Juhi Chawla won Filmfare award for Fresh Talent. Both were also nominated for Best Actor and Actress.

This success was followed by series of duds by the two including Love Love Love which was highly anticipated by the people as it released after QSQT but it failed critically and commercially.

The third film Tum Mere Ho was made by Aamir's father Tahir Hussain and is widely considered one of the worst films of Aamir Khan and though it did average business due to solid initials it is not considered a successful film because of bad reception.

To complete the hattrick of failures we had Daulat ki Jung in 1992 which was also a major critical and commercial failure.

In 1993 Aamir's father Tahir Hussain produced and Mahesh Bhatt directed Ham hai Rahi Pyar ke, which became a critical and commercial hit. Aamir Khan also co wrote the screenplay of the film. The film also won 2 National awards and Juhi Chawla won her only Filmfare for Best Actress. Aamir Khan was nominated for best actor.

In 1994 Juhi Chawla did a guest appearance in Andaz Apna Apna starring Aamir.

In 1995 Aamir Khan did a film with Juhi which he regrets doing. The film was Aatank hi Aatank based on Godfather. The film was heavily panned and failed badly. This is the only A rated film done by the Aamir Juhi pair.

Then came Ishq which was the last time the pair acted together. The two had a major fallout over some practical jokes made by Aamir which made Juhi cry and she skipped the shooting for a day. Rather than feeling sorry Aamir felt Juhi is wasting the time of the production house. Things escalated to the extent that they didn't talk to each other during the shooting and long after that. Till 2002 the duo were not in talking terms. Ishq was a commercial hit and Aamir was nominated for Best Actor Filmfare.

Monday, October 12, 2026

What are Nana Patekar's best movies?

 This is the list according to my taste and preference so it is subjective

Gaman (1978)- One of his earliest movies with hard hitting reality of the migrants, soul stirring music and masterful yet underrated direction of Muzzafar Ali. Good starting point for his film.

Ankush (1986)- Even though I didn't really like the way it portrayed the north Indians as gundas , the film reflects the angst of angry, restless and unemployed youth of the country. Inspired by Mere Apne (Ankush Director N Chandra was the assistant of Gulzar during Mere Apne) the film is realistic and hard hitting and yet tragic..

Parinda (1989)- One of the best films on underworld in Indian cinema with terrific performances by Jackie Shroff and Nana Patekar who won a National award for best supporting actor and Filmfare Best supporting actor. The film was also selected for Oscars from India.

Prahaar (1991)- Directorial debut of Nana Patekar. Nana Patekar's dedication to his craft in this film as a commando is commendable. He shines both as actor and director.

Diksha (1991): Most underrated movie of Nana Patekar. Nana Patekar plays a lower caste man and the film questions rituals and hypocrisy of society. Very understated performance.

Angaar (1992): Another underrated film of Nana Patekar for which he won Best Villain Filmfare. The film won 3 Filmfare and 1 National award. Based on the life of Karim Lala

Tiranga (1993): Nana's entry to Masala movies where he and Rajkumar made a formidable pair. And who can forget the Gaindaswamy and the fuse conductor.

Krantiveer (1994)- For me this film works only because if Nana Patekar. Otherwise the film is over the top and loud but Nana is brilliant. The biggest solo hit of Nana Patekar and won him his second National award.

Agnisakshi (1996)- Another brilliant performance by Nana. His role was spine chilling and he is the one who holds the film together. Another National Award for Nana.

Yeshwant (1997)- Hard hitting film and very good performance by Nana and Madhu.

Shakti the Power (2002): Powerful performance by Nana Patekar and Karishma Kapoor. Nana makes you hate his character with his performance

Ab Tak Chappan (2003)- Another film with Nana playing the ruthless cop who did 56 encounters. Devut film of Shimit Amin, who later directed Chak De India.

Apharan (2005)- Underrated film of Ajay, Nana and Prakash Jha. Won a National award for best screenplay Nana again plays a negative role with elan.

Taxi no 9211 (2006)- A feel good slice of life film which surprises you with its subtle humour and nuanced telling. Well acted and written.

Welcome (2007)- Nana’s foray into comedy and he had absolute blast along with Anil Kapoor. Who can forget Aloo le lo kanda le lo.

Natsamrat (2016)- one of the most celebrated roles of Marathi cinema and Nana lives up to the humungous expectations. One of the biggest hits if Marathi cinema.

Saturday, October 10, 2026

What are the top ten Bollywood films that were box office hits, but that have a lot of mistakes in them?

 

What are the top ten Bollywood films that were box office hits, but that have a lot of mistakes in them?

Rustom (2016)- made a mockery of the Nanavati case by completly changing the fact. In reality, Nanavati did k*ll the man for having affair with his wife, but because it was Akshay Kumar in a uniform they forced a deshbhakti wala angle to prove his innocence. In reality, even though the jury voted in his favour the judicial system refused to accept it and he was found guilty. The film is full of procedural errors (Akshay Kumar wearing his uniform during civil trials) and factual errors (in reality his wife herself confessed the affair, the deceased sister was shown in the film as vamp but in reality she was the one who ascended the letter of pardon for Nanavati to Vijaylaxmi Pandit).

Marykom (2015): The mistakes in this film are too many to count. They have shown father of Marykom unsupportive of her career when in reality he was the one who got her admitted to Sports Authority of India. The film show Marykom fighting an underground boxing to save her calf and there she met her future husband. In reality, she never did undrrground fight, the calf was sold to fund the coaching of Marykom at SAI and she got to know abut it much later. Also she met her husband at Hisar when her belongings were stolen and he delievered her passport for her to attend boxing tournament as he was studying at Delhi University at that time. Also her son was not having an operation during her World Championship games it happemed during Asian games that too the game was over way before the operation started and her sponsors funded tickets for her to come back to Chandigarh hospital before the operation started.

Gadar: The film gets the background of the period wrong. It takes the tragic story of Boota Singh and turns it into a mass masala film. In real life Boota singh’s wife was pregnant whenthey were running from the armed people. She gave birth to her child in a ditch and died while Boota singh stood guard. Also in the film Sakina’s family is singing Que Sera Sera in 1940s when that particular version of the song came out in 1956.

Bhaag Milkha Bhaag: This films invent and propogates the myth that Milkha lost the race because he turned his back and saw the partition memories and lost. In reality he was never in contention to win the race. Also he is seen singing Nanha Munha Rahi Hun in 1950s when the song was released in 1962.

Sholay: The buggest hit of Indian cinema has many illogical scenes including the water tanker scene because even though there is no electricity in thr village they have a water tanker.

Amar Akbar Anthony : Again so many illogical scenes like three people dispensing blood at the same time, Amitabh’s wounds shifting places, no one recognising the three brothers even though they are literally singing out loud their names!! Vinod khanna is able to remember and locate exactly where he hid his toy pistol 20 years ago and finds it in good condition!!

Om Shanti Om: The film is based in late 70s but show Mithun Chakraborty dancing in his trademark Disco Dancer style in the premiere of Shanti Priya movie, Sooraj Badjatya is seen copying the dialogues of Om which he will later use in Maine Pyar kiya, and Govinda is shown as a waiter all the events which didnt and couldnt happen in the 70s. Also the speech of Om in his first birth for award acceptance is different from his later speech. He gets the order of his servants wrong in the second half.

Hungama: in the beginning of the film, the lawyer of Presh Rawal tells him the story of Anandilal Kathpitiya, and asks him why he sent his son and daughter to foreign land, and Paresh also refer to them in plural, but later the film establishes that he only has one son. So where did the daughter go?

Disco Dancer: The film shows that the enemies of Jimmy attach a high voltage wire to his electric guitar to k*ll him, but his mother gets to know about it and she takes the guitar in her hand and d*es. Does an electric guitar really has that much voltage to kill someone? Not according to any available reports. And he develops Guitar Phobia?? (Scientists are yet to diagnose such a phobia!!)

Kuch Kuch Hota Hai: How was the girl able to read the first seven letters and what was written in those letters? How come Anjali never married when she must around or above 30 years old? How was Farida Jalal, Srk and Salman allowed to stay in the summer camp when no other parents were allowed?